Inheriting an IRA doesn't come with a manual. It comes with an account balance, a login, and, for most non-spouse beneficiaries since 2020, a ten-year clock that most people have never heard of until they're already holding the account and trying to figure out what to do with it.
What changed with the SECURE Act
Before 2020, a non-spouse beneficiary could typically stretch withdrawals from an inherited IRA across their own life expectancy, a strategy often called a "stretch IRA." The SECURE Act eliminated that option for most non-spouse beneficiaries of accounts inherited after 2020, replacing it with a requirement to fully deplete the account within ten years of the original owner's death. This is a meaningfully different set of tax timing questions than the stretch approach it replaced, and a lot of the general inherited-IRA advice still circulating online predates the change.
Who the 10-year rule applies to
The rule generally applies to what the IRS calls "non-eligible designated beneficiaries," which in practice covers most adult children and other non-spouse heirs. Certain beneficiaries are treated differently, and it's worth clarifying with a tax advisor which category applies to your specific situation before assuming the standard 10-year rule is what you're working with, since surviving spouses, minor children of the original owner, disabled or chronically ill beneficiaries, and beneficiaries less than ten years younger than the original owner each have different rules that can meaningfully change the timeline and the required withdrawal pattern.
Photo by RDNE Stock project on Pexels
Whether withdrawals are required each year, or just by year ten
This is one of the more confusing parts of the current rules, and it's genuinely been a source of back-and-forth IRS guidance since the SECURE Act passed. Depending on whether the original account owner had already started required minimum distributions before passing, beneficiaries may need to take annual withdrawals throughout the 10-year window in addition to fully depleting the account by year ten, rather than being free to wait and withdraw everything at once in year ten. Given how much this has shifted with subsequent IRS clarifications, this is exactly the kind of detail worth confirming directly with a tax advisor against the current rules rather than relying on an article, including this one, for the specific mechanics that apply to your inherited account today.
Why the timing of withdrawals matters beyond just compliance
Every dollar withdrawn from a traditional inherited IRA is generally taxed as ordinary income in the year it's withdrawn. Withdrawing the entire balance in year ten, rather than spreading withdrawals across the full window, can push a beneficiary into a higher tax bracket for that year than spreading the same total withdrawal across multiple years would. This is a genuinely complex planning question that depends on the beneficiary's other income, their marginal tax bracket in different years, and how the size of the inherited account compares to their regular income, which is exactly the kind of multi-year tax planning question worth working through with a tax advisor rather than deciding based on a general rule of thumb.
Roth versus traditional inherited IRAs
The 10-year depletion requirement applies to both Roth and traditional inherited IRAs, but the tax treatment of withdrawals differs substantially. Withdrawals from an inherited Roth IRA are generally tax-free if the original account met the Roth's holding period requirements, while withdrawals from a traditional inherited IRA are generally taxable as ordinary income. This difference changes the calculus around whether spreading withdrawals across the full ten years actually matters for tax purposes, since a beneficiary of a Roth account faces a different set of considerations than a beneficiary of a traditional account, even though both are subject to the same ten-year timeline.
Topics worth reviewing with a tax advisor before you decide
Which beneficiary category you fall into, since the timeline and annual withdrawal requirements differ meaningfully across the categories described above. Whether annual withdrawals are required during the 10-year window based on the original owner's RMD status at death. How withdrawal timing interacts with your other income in each of the next ten years, since a large single withdrawal can have a different tax impact than the same total spread out. Whether the account is a traditional or Roth IRA, and how that changes the tax treatment of withdrawals. Whether state tax rules add anything beyond the federal picture, since state treatment of inherited retirement accounts varies and isn't always aligned with federal rules.
Coordinating between a tax advisor and a financial advisor
An inherited IRA sits at the intersection of tax planning and broader financial planning, and it's a common gap for a beneficiary to get tax guidance on the withdrawal mechanics without anyone looking at how the timing interacts with the rest of their financial picture, retirement savings, other windfalls, existing investment accounts. Coordinating advisors so the tax and planning sides of this decision are actually talking to each other, rather than treated as two separate conversations, is worth raising explicitly rather than assuming it happens automatically.
What to clarify before choosing how to invest the account in the meantime
While the 10-year clock runs, the inherited IRA's assets remain invested, and how they're allocated is a separate question from the withdrawal timeline itself. Topics worth reviewing include how the account's current investments align with your own risk tolerance and time horizon, since an inherited account often carries the original owner's investment choices rather than ones the beneficiary actively selected, and whether it makes sense to review and potentially rebalance the account given your own financial situation rather than leaving it exactly as inherited.
What happens if withdrawals are missed
Missing a required annual withdrawal during the 10-year window, in situations where annual withdrawals apply, has historically carried a significant excise tax penalty on the amount that should have been withdrawn. The IRS has issued transition relief waiving this penalty in certain years while the post-SECURE Act guidance was still being finalized, which is exactly the kind of detail that changes from year to year and is worth confirming as current before assuming either that a penalty applies or that relief is automatically available. This is a clear example of why a general overview, including this one, isn't a substitute for checking the rules as they stand in the specific year you're making a decision.
Multiple inherited IRAs and how they interact
A beneficiary who inherits more than one IRA, whether from the same original owner or from different people, may need to treat each inherited account separately for purposes of the 10-year rule and any annual withdrawal requirements, rather than assuming the accounts can simply be combined and managed as one. Whether and how inherited accounts can be aggregated for withdrawal purposes is a detail worth reviewing directly with a tax advisor, since getting it wrong can affect whether the required withdrawal pattern was actually satisfied.
How this differs from inheriting a non-retirement account
It's worth naming explicitly that the tax treatment here is specific to retirement accounts. An inherited brokerage account or inherited real estate generally receives a stepped-up cost basis and doesn't carry the same ordinary-income tax treatment on withdrawal that a traditional inherited IRA does. Beneficiaries who inherit a mix of account types, a traditional IRA alongside a taxable brokerage account, for instance, are often dealing with genuinely different tax rules for each one simultaneously, which is one more reason a single conversation covering the whole inherited estate, not just the IRA in isolation, tends to surface considerations that reviewing each account separately can miss.
A decision that benefits from more than a general article
The specifics here shift with IRS guidance, vary by beneficiary category, and interact with a beneficiary's individual tax situation in ways a general overview genuinely can't resolve. Capivise's advisor matching service connects people navigating exactly this kind of decision with vetted financial advisors who work through inherited account questions regularly, rather than leaving beneficiaries to piece together the current rules from scattered, sometimes outdated sources. You can see what the matching process actually involves, or review what to ask an advisor before your first conversation.
Where to check the current rules directly
The IRS's page on required minimum distributions is the primary source for the current mechanics of the 10-year rule, and it's worth checking directly since guidance has been clarified more than once since the SECURE Act passed. Investor.gov, the SEC's investor education site, has plain-language background on inherited retirement accounts and beneficiary designations more broadly. The CFP Board's consumer site is a solid, non-commercial resource for understanding what a certified financial planner's role looks like in a situation like this, useful context before you start a search for an advisor. FINRA's investor resources round this out with background on how inherited accounts are typically administered by custodians, which is worth understanding before you're on the phone with one sorting out the logistics.
The version of this that actually matters
Ten years sounds like a long runway, and in one sense it is, but the tax decisions inside that window, when to withdraw, how much, and how the account is invested in the meantime, benefit from planning early rather than defaulting to a single large withdrawal in year nine because the deadline suddenly feels close. Reviewing the specifics with a tax advisor shortly after you inherit the account, rather than waiting, gives you the most room to actually plan around the tax impact rather than reacting to it, and it gives a financial advisor room to weigh in on how the timing fits your broader plan before the decision has effectively already been made by default.
